Monday, March 3, 2014

Reagan's 600 Ship Fleet

So since I have another snow day (ridiculous), I've been up all night and my thoughts wandered onto the subject of Ronald Reagan and the 600 ship fleet. 600 ships is a massive number so I've decided to compile a list of what that might look like using today's naval ship classes.

For reference I will first compile a list of the current US Navy (283 ships total, plus 122 Civilian Marine Sealift)

10 Aircraft Carriers (Nimitz, Ford Classes)
9 Amphibious Assault Shils (Wasp, Tarawa, America classes)
10 Amphibious Dock Ships (Austin, San Antonio classes) 
12 Dock Landing Ships (Whidbey Island, Harpers Ferry classes)
22 cruisers (Ticonderoga class)
62 (Arleigh Burke Class, Zumwalt class) 
17 frigates (Oliver Hazard Perry class)
3 littoral combat ships (Freedom and Independence classes) 
71 submarines (Ohio, Los Angeles, Sewolf and Virginia classes)

For a total of 216 Combat Ships out of a 283(+122) ship navy for a grand total of 405 ships. So what might a 600 ship navy look like? 

600 Ship Navy:
15 Aircraft Carriers
20 Amphibious Assault Ships
20 Amphibious Dock Ships
20 Dock Landing ships 
22 Cruisers (CG(X) Class)
91 Destroyers (Arleigh Burke class, Flights 2,3,4)
30 Zumwalt Class Destroyers
55 Littoral Combat Ships
100 Attack Submarines (Los Angeles, Seawolf, Virginia classes)
35 SSNBs (Ohio class+ phased in Replacement class)

So right there I have 408 combat ships, which is more than the entire ship total for the current US Navy. That isn't 600 though, but I haven't factored in other ships such as Minesweepers, Cyclone class patrol boats, the fate of the remaining Oliver Hazard Perry Frigates (Which are being phased out and replaced with the LCS program), Sea Lift capabilities, hospital ships, and the civilian ships the Navy operates. All totaled I estimate the number would be aroud 600 so I did pretty well.

Some changes I made to Navy that I wanted to talk about: 

Cruisers: Our current Ticonderoga class cruisers are scheduled for retirement and will not have a replacement, instead their role will be filled by the third flight of the Arleigh Burke Class Destroyer. The CG(X) program, essentially a cruiser class for the 21st century was cancelled due to monetary considerations, however I am ignoring the money here and bringing them back to replace the Ticonderogas on a ship-by-ship basis.

Destoyers- I decided to bump the number of Zumwalt class Destroyers from 3 to 30, again ignoring money. These destroyers would serve as our primary land attack ship, being stealthy enough to avoid detection, slip into the littorals, and launch a crud ton of missiles into the enemy. This ship does have shortcomings, but all ships do. As for the 91 Arleigh Burke destoyers, the US Navy has a requirement for the 2020's and beyond to have 91 ships that are sufficent in Theater Ballistic Missile protection. I decided to use the Arleigh Burkes to completely fill this requirement, since these shils are tested and probably the best at sea for filling the multiple roles of Anti-submarine, Anti-aircraft, Anti-ship, and Anti-Ballistic Missile warfare. 

And finally, the LCS program: I kept all 55 planned LCS, which even the Navy has cut down to 32. However in my mind, the US Navy would scrap the current two designs and go after an entirely new class of ships. I would nominate a modified version of the Swedish Visby class corvettes, so that they have more endurance, and more helicopter capability. These ships are cheaper and more efficent at doing the same jobs the LCS is supposed to do, and most importantly, are combat survivable, unlike the LCS. 

An Alternative to the Current Round of Defense Cuts

Last week Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel announced that the US Army would be cut to a size not seen since before World War Two. The Navy is cutting the number of ships it has and rumors are it may retire another aircraft carrier. The AirForce will most likely be cutting down on the number of F-35's it purchases and future purchases of things such as the Long Range Stealth Bomber.

In my view the Pentagon needs to face reductions of its budget, but not in this way. The way we are cutting the military right now is quite frankly just plain dumb. As much of a left-winger as I am, I am also a pragmatist and I know that we cannot secure a peaceful world that is safe for democracy without a strong military. Many on the left believe that if the US would unilaterally disarm and stop "meddling" then the war and strife on this planet would cease. They say it isn't the place of America to be the world's policeman. 

These people-many of whom I admire and respect- are wrong. If the US disarms or starts cutting down its military and withdrawing from it's foreign bases then it will create a power vacuum. The nations that step into this vacuum will not be democracies and friendly nations. Europe will not start arming up and taking care of its own defense, the Middle East will not be able to defend against Iran for long. Taiwan, South Korea, The Phillipines and Japan would be at the mercy of China. While all these nations do have militaries, many with large budgets and advanced weaponry (The Phillipines being the exception), they don't have the equipment, manpower or resources to build up militaries capable of standing up to Russia, Iran, China, North Korea and hunt down terrorists. The US military is the one thing detering thise nations from pursuing an even more aggressive foreign policy- does anyone really think that if the US was not around that China wouldn't have invaded Taiwan already? Or that China wouldn't have seized the Spratley and Parcel Islands in the South China Sea? Who honestly thinks that North Korea would not have attacked the South again if the US did not have 30,000 troops stationed there with support from our bases in Japan?

Whether we like it or not, the US is the World's policeman. We have to be. There is no other nation or international NGO capable of doing so. The UN is hamstringed by the Security Council deadlock, the EU is primarily an economic union, but the militaries of Europe-even those of NATO- are logistically hamstrung by the fact that they are not integrated commands with one chain of command but many separate militaries with different equipment, different languages and different chains of command. Russia and China are expansionist and authoritarian, and the role of policing the world should not be left up to them. Thus naturally it falls upon the United States, as the world's first modern democracy, the most powerful military and largest economy on the globe to be the world's policeman. There is nothing inherently wrong with this role, in fact the US should actively embrace it. Yes we have made mistakes, Iraq in 2003, the Occupation of Afghanistan and the Vietnam War, alongside many smaller interventions like the invasion of Panama and the Iran-Contra scandal. Yes, we need safeguards against further mistakes, but to hamstring our military and simply deny ourselves  military capacity is not the right way to do so, especially not when China and Russia are on the rise and North Korea is as belligerent as ever. 

So how should the United States sustain it's military capacity in a fiscally responsible way? I will present my alternatives here:
1) Pull out of Afghanistan completely. Close bases in surrounding countries that are useful only for the occupation effort. This would save the taxpayers upwards of $60 Billion a year.
2) Clean out the defense department. The average estimate for waste at the Pentagon is over $70 billion annually. 
3) Stop procurement of weapons that the Pentagon doesn't need or want and allow the Pentagon to close unnecessary bases.
4) Stop buying products before the Pentagon knows they work. A great example is the LCS (Littoral Combat Ship) program. The builders should have had to build the ships and the Navy should have fully reviewed these ships before purchasing them. The F-35 program is another example- make sure the product works before you buy thousands of them. That said I am not in favor of cancelling the F-35 program.
6) Cancel the LCS program. These ships are not rated as combat survivable by the Pentagon, are less efficent than other ships being built by other nations with the same goals in mind, and are poorly constructed. 
7) Prioritize based on strategy. The United States military must think practically about future conflicts. With most future conflicts, it is likely they will be counter-insurgency conflicts like Iraq and Afghanistan. The United States needs to prioritize special forces and air support in these wars. In most major wars, our possible enemies include (But are not limited to): Russia, North Korea, Iran and China. Realistically we cannot hope to invade Russia or China effectively and they cannot hope to invade the United States. Conflict with Russia would be limited to Eastern Europe, with minor fighting in the Arctic and Pacific. Conflict with China would primarily occur in the waters surrounding China and the countries nearby: Taiwan, South Korea, Japan, The Philippines, Malaysia and potentially Vietnam. China has no major amphibious forces that could effectively execute a major sea-based invasion. Thus such a war would be Air-Sea-Cyber. We already have the troops in place to defend our allies against North Korea. Iran is the one country the US could have to invade, but what is more likely is a large scale air campaign targeted at first against their air defense network and then at the government. What all this essentially means is that the emphasis of our military needs to focus on Naval, Air, and Cyber operations with limited focus on ground operations.

Foreign Policy thoughts on a snow day

Welp I have a snow day and that means I can either do even more redundant SAT studying or I can blog to my heart's content today. So I figured I'd start off with Foreign Policy since thats the big topic of the week, more specifically the Ukraine Crisis.

So as we all know, the pro-EU Ukrainians forced the kinda sorta pro-Russian president to flee and have set up a new transitional government in Kiev until elections could be held in May. Armed men in uniforms without insignia siezed airports in the Crimea region of the Ukraine, the only region with a majority of ethnic Russians. Then Putin asked the Russian Duma (their parliament) to authorize troop use in the Ukraine and basically admitted it was Russian troops in the Crimean peninsula. So now Russian troops are flooding into Crimea as the new Ukrainian government calls up the reservists (one estimate says over 3 million have reported for duty), and pro-Russian demonstrations are breaking out in the East of the country. 

Before we get to talk of what the US response should be (The mainstream media just skipped this part an went straight to "The biggest test of the Obama presidency), the legitimacy of the new government in Kiev needs to be debated, as well as the legitimacy of the  Russian actions.

 A lot of people on the left whom I respect (I'm not talking about the liberal left, I'm talking about the progressive and socialist left) side with Russia in this moment. Essentially their view is that the EU deal with the Ukraine is only going to encourage the economic imperialism of Western Europe, and further the expansion of NATO into Eastern Europe. There are legitimate criticisms of the new Ukrainian government, such as the presence of neo-nazis and fascists, and that can't be ignored (although the western media does a great job of that), but this ignores the actual source of conflict in the Ukraine. This is less of an ideological conflict than a struggle over the cultural identity of the people of the Ukraine. In the Western portion of the Ukraine, most people speak Ukrainian, while in the East, most people speak Russian. Crimea is an autonomous republic located on the Crimean peninsula (still a part of the Ukraine however) and has an ethnic makeup that is majority Russian. 

Essentially this conflict can be boiled down to two sides (although there are others, these are the main sides in the conflict) The Ukrainian speakers who are essentially pro-European integration and the Russian speakers who want closer ties with Russia and to move away from Europe. 

The way the Government of the Ukraine was overthrown waa completely legitimate. It was not protesters storming the President's residence and putting him on trial or anything like mob rule, the parliament of the Ukraine ousted the president and took control. A legitimate government institution asserted the powers it possess and used them to oust a president and appoint an interim leadership until elections could be held in May. The new government in Kiev is the legitimate government of the Ukraine. 

Now we must look at the legitimacy of the Russian actions. Russia has a naval base in Crimea, the largest in their Black Sea Fleet. It was a legitimate concern that the base would need increased security measures because of the instability in the surrounding country. However the Russian fleet only has a base there at the pleasure of the Ukrainian host government. The Russians feared that the bew pro-European government in Kiev would force them out, so the Russians essentially ensured that the government of Crimea was pro-Russian and then siezed the peninsula. That was an act of aggression, it was the theft of the legitimate territory of the soverign nation of the Ukraine. The Russian actions in the Ukraine are wrong and as such are not legitimate. 

So yes, the US needs to respond to this Russian aggression in a way that is more forceful than 90 minute phone calls and the vague threat of consequences. Many on the liberal and progressive left say that the US has no moral authorith on the subject of wrongful invasion because of Iraq. And yes, I agree with them. However that doesn't mean the US should just stand idly by in this situation. By doing that we are essentially telling the world that wrongful invasion of a country is an ok thing to do now. Russia has become an aggressor and not just in the Ukraine. The invasion of Georgia, the aid to Syria and Iran, all are actions of aggression and the mark of a new age of Russian expansionism and empire. Just because the US made a mistake does not mean we should allow aggression to go unchecked. 

So what options should the US (and by extension Europe) exercise? 
First the US needs to call a meeting of the UN Security council, and even thiugh Russia and possiby China will veto a resolution, they need to be forced into that position. Secondly the EU needs to announce that they will be exploring the further use of Norwegian and Scottish oil and gas. The US and Canada also need to start directing their oil and gas exports to the EU to help diversify their sources of oil and gas away from dependence on Russia. The EU must begin the quest for Energy independence. Third the US and EU need to place sanctions on Russian exports and officials. Travel bans need to be enacted as well. It goes without saying that no US official should have any dealings with Russia and as such we need to withdraw the ambassador in Moscow and withdraw from any cooperation with Russia. Lastly the NATO countries need to stage military exercises in Poland that simulate defending against a Russian invasion of Europe and naval exercises with Turkey and other NATO nations in the Black Sea, that simulate an attempt by Russia to force open the Bosporus and Dardanelles straits. 

If it does come to open war between the Ukraine and Russia then I would move that the United States and NATO supply the Ukrainian government and military with both non-military items (food, tolietries, medicine, etc) and some military items (firearms, ammunition, night -vision goggles, etc. but stopping short of tanks, artillery, aircraft and the like). And if the Russians protest then we can cite Russian help to Syria as an example, and hit them over the head in the international press and community that we are aiding a nation that wants the right to self-determination while Russia is an expansionist power that aids dictators like Al-Assad who use WMDs against their own citizens.