In my view the Pentagon needs to face reductions of its budget, but not in this way. The way we are cutting the military right now is quite frankly just plain dumb. As much of a left-winger as I am, I am also a pragmatist and I know that we cannot secure a peaceful world that is safe for democracy without a strong military. Many on the left believe that if the US would unilaterally disarm and stop "meddling" then the war and strife on this planet would cease. They say it isn't the place of America to be the world's policeman.
These people-many of whom I admire and respect- are wrong. If the US disarms or starts cutting down its military and withdrawing from it's foreign bases then it will create a power vacuum. The nations that step into this vacuum will not be democracies and friendly nations. Europe will not start arming up and taking care of its own defense, the Middle East will not be able to defend against Iran for long. Taiwan, South Korea, The Phillipines and Japan would be at the mercy of China. While all these nations do have militaries, many with large budgets and advanced weaponry (The Phillipines being the exception), they don't have the equipment, manpower or resources to build up militaries capable of standing up to Russia, Iran, China, North Korea and hunt down terrorists. The US military is the one thing detering thise nations from pursuing an even more aggressive foreign policy- does anyone really think that if the US was not around that China wouldn't have invaded Taiwan already? Or that China wouldn't have seized the Spratley and Parcel Islands in the South China Sea? Who honestly thinks that North Korea would not have attacked the South again if the US did not have 30,000 troops stationed there with support from our bases in Japan?
Whether we like it or not, the US is the World's policeman. We have to be. There is no other nation or international NGO capable of doing so. The UN is hamstringed by the Security Council deadlock, the EU is primarily an economic union, but the militaries of Europe-even those of NATO- are logistically hamstrung by the fact that they are not integrated commands with one chain of command but many separate militaries with different equipment, different languages and different chains of command. Russia and China are expansionist and authoritarian, and the role of policing the world should not be left up to them. Thus naturally it falls upon the United States, as the world's first modern democracy, the most powerful military and largest economy on the globe to be the world's policeman. There is nothing inherently wrong with this role, in fact the US should actively embrace it. Yes we have made mistakes, Iraq in 2003, the Occupation of Afghanistan and the Vietnam War, alongside many smaller interventions like the invasion of Panama and the Iran-Contra scandal. Yes, we need safeguards against further mistakes, but to hamstring our military and simply deny ourselves military capacity is not the right way to do so, especially not when China and Russia are on the rise and North Korea is as belligerent as ever.
So how should the United States sustain it's military capacity in a fiscally responsible way? I will present my alternatives here:
1) Pull out of Afghanistan completely. Close bases in surrounding countries that are useful only for the occupation effort. This would save the taxpayers upwards of $60 Billion a year.
2) Clean out the defense department. The average estimate for waste at the Pentagon is over $70 billion annually.
3) Stop procurement of weapons that the Pentagon doesn't need or want and allow the Pentagon to close unnecessary bases.
4) Stop buying products before the Pentagon knows they work. A great example is the LCS (Littoral Combat Ship) program. The builders should have had to build the ships and the Navy should have fully reviewed these ships before purchasing them. The F-35 program is another example- make sure the product works before you buy thousands of them. That said I am not in favor of cancelling the F-35 program.
6) Cancel the LCS program. These ships are not rated as combat survivable by the Pentagon, are less efficent than other ships being built by other nations with the same goals in mind, and are poorly constructed.
7) Prioritize based on strategy. The United States military must think practically about future conflicts. With most future conflicts, it is likely they will be counter-insurgency conflicts like Iraq and Afghanistan. The United States needs to prioritize special forces and air support in these wars. In most major wars, our possible enemies include (But are not limited to): Russia, North Korea, Iran and China. Realistically we cannot hope to invade Russia or China effectively and they cannot hope to invade the United States. Conflict with Russia would be limited to Eastern Europe, with minor fighting in the Arctic and Pacific. Conflict with China would primarily occur in the waters surrounding China and the countries nearby: Taiwan, South Korea, Japan, The Philippines, Malaysia and potentially Vietnam. China has no major amphibious forces that could effectively execute a major sea-based invasion. Thus such a war would be Air-Sea-Cyber. We already have the troops in place to defend our allies against North Korea. Iran is the one country the US could have to invade, but what is more likely is a large scale air campaign targeted at first against their air defense network and then at the government. What all this essentially means is that the emphasis of our military needs to focus on Naval, Air, and Cyber operations with limited focus on ground operations.
No comments:
Post a Comment